Showing posts with label Thoughts. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Thoughts. Show all posts

Monday, May 28, 2012

Chance knowledge and the cumulative effect

As I was driving past a park this Saturday, I saw that a section of it was burning. I suddenly had a vivid image of the entire park burning with high flames (It is a very large park). This then caused a thought about how Rome would have looked to Nero as it burnt. The revelation – I now know why Nero (the software) is so named.




This sort of random revelation is not an unusual thing. The most important part here was that I wasn’t thinking about computers at all. The experience was quite Sherlock Holmes-ish – When he gives voice to Dr. Watson’s thoughts by saying “Such a waste” and then proceeds to explain the chain of thought in the latter’s mind. Richard Bach compared ideas to fractures running in a crystal – any could lead to any other. Others have referred to the oneness of knowledge – that given one thing, everything else could be discovered. Both seem somewhat limited ways of explaining the experience.

Chance discoveries happen in science all the time. Microwave background radiation and radioactivity  are but two examples.

I’m thinking now of the cumulative nature of scientific knowledge. Both socio-economic theorists (Farcis Fukuyama, Fareed Zakaria etc.) and scientists (Francis Bacon) assert that with the invention of the scientific method (hypothesis-experiment-prove/disprove), scientific knowledge has become cumulative. That later generation inherit the knowledge of their predecessors. And it is intuitively true. We don’t have to rediscover the gravitational principle, although we may have to prove it several times over (damned CBSE exams!).

This is brought into somewhat contrary focus by the revelational experience. The cumulative nature of the scientific method no doubt holds true when the steps are small. Not to belittle any discoveries, but some _are_ greater than others. It took a Newton to get us to gravity, and even more drastically, an Einstein to get to relativity. Both works are quite out of the league for their times. The tools they used were there, as was the a-priori knowledge. But the power of the method seems to wane when we consider efforts where accepted first principles have to be discarded.

The cumulativity assertion says that given a state of human knowledge and the scientific method – the future can be worked out again. But how does this apply when the prior knowledge has to be discarded by a leap of faith.  When accidents force the next step forward, how does the scientific principle handle it? We can say that the geniuses use informed intuition (Kekule and the structure of Benzene). But that would lead us into the myriad definitions of genius and intuition.

And that’s a discussion for some other time.

Thursday, May 24, 2012

Technology, not activism, will save the environment

A lot of people are interested in preserving the environment. I admit I don’t do much about it (I’m more the armchair sort), but I am interested in it. To those who are out there doing it (planting trees, spotfixing etc.) - more power to you!! You have my respect. This post has nothing to do with you. This is about the people who are corporate bitches of the “sustainable business practices” variety. I will say this out loud and clearly – That shit don’t work. Let me explain why.

What does “sustainable business practices” mean? It means that we will continue to do business with just about enough tweaks to it so that it allows the self-same business to run a little longer. If the tagline gets us a few tax breaks, so much the better. I don’t know of any company which has drastically changed business models or made business decisions on the basis of sustainability. Sustainability is good PR, but it is faaaaaar down the table from the bottom line. The jobs I referred to exist for posterity, and to employ mavericks who are willing to work for low salaries and pointless objectives.

Think about it. In the first place, the concept that we can somehow undo the damage we have done to the environment is kind of suspect. We can stop it from getting worse if we abandon all polluting activities right this instant, but the ecology of a planet is an immense beast, and is not easily turned from its path. Apart from that, the scale at which we are screwing things up is huge. Optimizations to the existing products/processes can only buy some time before the jig is up. Besides, let’s face it – corporates don’t truly care about environment. This is not to say that people working there don’t care, but usually when “The firm comes first”, clean air comes last.

Henry Ford (the first) said – “For an idea to work, it has to be right in time, and it has to be right in price”. Meaning someone making very expensive horse-buggies in 1900 would be wrong in price, and someone making very cheap horse-buggies today would be wrong in time.  Neither would work. Today, the idea of environmental conservation is right in time, but I think that it is still wrong in price. We simply do not have economically viable substitutes for most of the stuff that is going wrong. This is why I firmly believe that the tide will turn not by activism, but by technology.

Activism is a fine thing, but it is not the solution here. It simply does not scale well. What we need is new, clean technology that performs at least as well as the current polluting setup. Only once we have these alternates is when the battle can be joined in the earnest by switching businesses to use them and making the enterprises actually sustainable.

New products that are cheap and yet eco-friendly will be immensely disruptive to the existing system. This is historically consistent (significant changes in living conditions occurs with significant change in technology) and the only hope that we have of turning the development juggernaut on its head and setting it in the right (or at least somewhat) direction. But since it is disruptive, it will face opposition, and THEN we will need environmental managers to carry the standard into boardrooms. But first that solution(s) that can be peddled has to be discovered.

So, here’s my tuppence – If you truly, deeply care about environment, go study the sciences. Try to actually solve the problem. Don’t waste your time and effort getting a corporate degree in Environmental Practices (or whatever they call it). It will be irrelevant and useless.

Tuesday, May 22, 2012

Intelligence and Wisdom

A trip to a forest resort the last weekend set me thinking about the differences and intelligence and wisdom. Nothing obvious happened to cause this. Our host just mentioned that he dropped out of college to live in the wilderness which he has now done for 32 years with his family. For all that, he seemed to be a happy. That set the ball rolling. So let me set out what I think about these two characteristics.

Intelligence is the ability to learning skills that allow for solution of specific problems. It is the ability to apply abstract concepts to some tangible ends or to discover further new concepts (that could also be considered a tangible end, but those who think of philosophy as unproductive are likely to differ). Intelligence manifests itself in smartness and incisive analysis. But these are only how intelligence expresses itself.

At its essence, intelligence is an outward seeking force. Given an intellect and a limited amount of knowledge, it seeks to push the boundaries of our understanding by adding new concepts and generalizations. It is the origin of rationality and of science. It causes progress (in the usual, materialistic of the word at least) – the evolution from monkey to man and from poor man to rich man. There is no point in asking Intelligence to stop. It is an ambitious force, and its march is relentless. It is its own fuel.  Its own fruits feed it to become ever greater. In a way, it is the yang that drives the world.


Wisdom is the ability to make the best, but not necessarily the most efficient choice, in a situation. It is not intuition (which is, IMO, another word for internalizing something so deeply that it comes without conscious thought – martial arts uses it, so does guitar playing), but rather an ability to judge the importance of things. It expresses itself in patience, far-sightedness, and restraint. Not that these qualities are deprived to intelligence, but wisdom is the true master of them. But these again are expressions.

On the other hand, Wisdom is an inward seeking force (Not in any mystical way, though). It tries to contract our world, reduce it to its basics. Intelligence wants the world and what lies beyond, but wisdom makes its business the setting of priorities. It allows us to stay focused on the things that truly matters to us. It is born of temperance does not invest its energy in exuberant causes. Neither is it bothered by trivial detail. Its nature is to be still. It is the yin of the world, stability incarnate.




Though either or both may be had in various degrees, it would not be correct, I think, to choose one over the other. We need one to control the other, one to move ahead and the other to restrain a headlong rush into madness. An intelligence tempered by wisdom or a wisdom powered by an intellect are formidable forces indeed.

Balance.

Thursday, May 17, 2012

Because we need them



I absolutely loved Avengers. But here, I don’t want to talk about the complete absence of plot, the kickass action, Robert Downey Jr.’s Tony Stark, or the God who got bullied (Note that I just slyly did talk about all these things).

I want to talk about power. And I want to talk about free will.

The movie ends with Samuel Jackson saying – “(The Avengers will return…) Because we need them”.  No one seems to notice it, but I find it to be an extremely disturbing thought. This bunch of extremely powerful personages is to be at our beck and call because we need them!

What is it that makes a hero (in the sense of DC or Marvel)? Is it a unique ability? Is it the desire for adulation? I don’t know. But what is clear is that the motives lead to vastly different actions. Anyone seeking public admiration will of course have to perform acts of public welfare. The greater the hunger for admiration, the greater will have to be the services rendered and the possible cost of them. And the reverse works too, the more the people love you, the more you are expected to deliver. It seems fine thus far unless we realize that this is also the clear highway to megalomania. But we know that Captain America is not a megalomaniac. Neither is Iron Man (Stark is, but not his steel clad avatar), or Hawkeye, or any of the others.

What about their unique ability? This is where the question of free will comes in. Anyone with a unique ability is just that-nothing more. Does this situation rob them of the choice to not participate? Is a quirk of birth or fate enough to necessarily deprive a person of choosing what they wish to be committed to? Should Bruce Banner give in to the all-devouring god of our need and embrace “the other guy” (whom he hates, BTW). If he wishes to withdraw into the medical profession and never “Smash” again, is that not his prerogative? But alas, society gives no such choices to its mighty.

And in all this, let’s see where Nick Fury stands. He does nothing in the whole damn movie. He originally rejects Stark from the Avengers initiative because of instability. And then has the cheek to pull him in as soon as fighting begins. There is no indication that Tony Stark is any more stable at this point. He deigns to command a team of people who are infinitely greater than him in all aspects. And why does he expect them to obey? Because he needs them. It's a confidence ploy, emotional blackmail to abuse power that is not his own. The ends, however noble, do not justify the means.

”Is there trouble? Let’s call in the band of poor sods whom we insulted when we didn’t need them. Of course they will come. Don’t we need them? Our need comes before their free will.” Flashes of Atlas Shrugged anyone?

“With great power comes great responsibility” seems to me to be an incomplete statement. It is the willingness to wield power which brings responsibility. The mere possession of power is a triviality, a happenstance. It changes nothing about who or what we are. It is when we choose to exercise this power is when we face the choice of how to do it. The use of power is an ethical dilemma, which may make one a hero or a villain (again depending on who is writing the story).

In short, I found the concept reprehensible and I left an excellent movie with a rather bad taste in my mouth. I have written thus far in the context of the movie and that one line in it. But generalize and see if it isn’t true of the world and our society in general. Imagine an acquaintance, powerful in some way, but who didn’t grant you a favour because he doesn’t care enough about you. Would you feel cheated simply because you think he should do it?

Then pity the avengers.

Wednesday, May 16, 2012

Reductio ad absurdum

Today I had a most interesting conversation about religion with my friend Tarun Runwal. He is a confessed agnostic, I am a militant atheist. When the two meet, you know who was defending god. Both of us were slightly drunk on Urban Asia’s excellent LIITs too.

A point that Tarun repeatedly made that I found both effective and exasperating was that of the first cause. It is not a novel argument in favour of deism, but I have never personally seen it used so doggedly. For the uninitiated, it goes like this – scientifically speaking, there was a beginning. Who/What caused it? If it is explained in the first degree, then the argument can be repeated to the n-th degree without losing any validity (at least superficially). If the n-th degree situation can’t be explained be explained rationally, then what right do we have to completely dismiss god from the equation? He/She/It could have caused it.

I would like to approach this by considering the nature of questions in general. A question is valid if it is answerable, at least to some extent. A chicken-egg question is not a valid question, IMO. If every possible answer of a question can be the subject of the original question, then the question is invalid. Some readers might liken this to a situation where some senior manager asks a junior guy something. The junior guy starts from an answer that is relevant in detail to his level of expertise. The senior fellow keeps on repeating the question, the junior keeps moving to a lesser and lesser detail in his answer. This happens till both are satisfied. This is a fairly familiar scenario (at least where I come from). If no answer of the junior would ever be high-level enough, then this exercise would never end and we are forced to conclude that the line of questioning is wrong in some way.

This is the nature of a scientific inquiry. We are trying to explain phenomenon at a suitably high level. We start with an empirical hypothesis and push it outwards based on observed or proven facts, and generalize it to the level our information allows us (no more – A junior who reported imaginary things to his manager would no doubt be fired soon). If, however, we see that no amount of data or analysis is going to explain a phenomenon, we should perceive that there is a problem with the statement of the phenomenon itself.
Religion these days finds its last stand in such reductio ad absurdum kind of questions. The theologians realize that there is no logical way to solve these, and house there gods in their shelter. My argument against these is that the universe is what it is. You cannot gainsay the nature of nature. The aim of science and reason is not to indulge in endless logical frivolities, but to reveal to us the underlying laws that govern nature. As Richard Feynman famously put it, it is like watching a game of chess, of which we can only see some parts at some times. Our understanding needs to be reverse engineered from these glimpses. That being said, there is only a certain level to which this understanding can be reduced or generalised (Just like there are only so many ways to explain the move of a pawn in chess). Beyond this, causality becomes meaningless. “Why moves the knight thus?” would have no meaning in chess. The same is true in physics.

Reductio ad absurdum is a useful technique, but it should be applied in context. This is why the anthropic principle is such a powerful and effective technique in physics – it allows us to separate the crap question from the relevant ones.

Infinite regression is the refuge of the morally and intellectually bankrupt. Anybody who wants to have meaningful philosophical discussion about anything should avoid it.

Monday, May 14, 2012

The Great Indian Political Circus

I usually don’t think about politics, but a recent re-reading of Freedom at Midnight and The Great Indian Novel gave some interesting insights into the current Indian political circus. As is usual with my insights, it isn’t really an insight. It’s just a general mess of thoughts, cleared up and come together in one statement – Our politics is messed up because we know how to protest, but not how to govern.

I believe this is due to our political legacy.

Freedom at Midnight relates how immediately after independence, our revered leader proved absolutely incapable of administering their new found nation. They knew how to protest, how to hold rallies against government laws, but they had no experience in making and enforcing laws themselves. So when the communal backlash of the partition refused to abate, they were forced to call in Lord Mountbatten to contain the violence. Only with his behind-the-curtains intervention did normalcy return. Jawaharlal Nehru deserves every bit of credit he is given today as a leader of Independence struggle, but he is not quite the role model of leadership and governance. He, however, is the paragon of politics whom our leaders choose to emulate today.

The second part of my thought process came from The Great Indian Novel and the Anna Hazaare movement. Both refer to periods where people took to the streets in direct opposition to policies of the government (Anna ji’s case being that of protests against an absolute lack of policies from the government). Both battles were fought on the streets, and both were wildly successful in mobilizing the public against the government (actual results notwithstanding). On neither occasion did the protesting party offer a viable administrative alternative (The Janata Party government formed of Shri Jaiprakash Narain’s movement died without a whimper).

This is not to suggest that protesting is wrong or that someone who can’t be a great prime minister should just shut up. Citizen activism has its part to play in the balance of power. The strange problem is in when concept of activism and its success are hijacked. It gives the impression that whoever can muster the most people on the street can govern regardless of who holds the majority in the parliament. It is a parallel democracy where “for the people” is taken literally to be the headcount of a rally. I am not well versed with the politics of many countries but I believe that this may be unique to the largest democracy in the world.

The problem is in the complete abandonment of governance in favour of protests. Neither the ruling nor the opposition parties today choose to use the parliament as the forum for decision making, nor are election the favoured means to oust a party that has lost the popular mandate. The chosen means of everything is a “popular” circus. But as a correspondent wrote about Baba Ramdev’s dharna, when you organize a circus, sooner or later the clowns will arrive.

The business of politicians is to make policies. This is best done by sitting down and deliberating, not by shouting on the streets. Our politics is messed up because we know how to protest but not how to govern. Our political role models did not know how to govern either, and their legendary status has left an incorrect but lasting impression that their way is the way. It isn’t. 

Saturday, October 8, 2011

Role of a trader

Full Disclosure - I am a programmer for a hedge fund.

In all societies in the past, a person's income was directly linked to his/her role in society. Agricultural societies rewarded farmers, warlike societies rewarded soldiers and democratic societies rewarded statesmen. This is not to say that the system was fair or that everyone got what they deserved, but there was a general connection between the craft that was the primary source of a society's prosperity and the status of the practitioners of that craft.

Traders and investment bankers are among the highly paid professionals of our times.And yet somehow I am unable to understand the role they play in our world. As in I understand the role, but not its significance to our lives. What would happen in no trading was done for a week?

The role of a professional trader emerged as a side effect of development of excellent means of transportation. With farmers and craftsmen able to ship their goods far and wide, it became impossible for them to personally be present at the site where theie wares were being traded. Thus emerged the trader-someone who would charge some money in exchange for buying/selling on your behalf. And it is in strictly this role that the function of the trader is critical. Such trading has to be done in order for assets to circulate in society. Here actual assets get introduced into the economy  via the trading function. The trader is essentially as assistant for those creating real assets and value.

Now consider the role of the stock market trader as we see it today. This trader does not generate any assets in the system. By merely playing off one asset against another (No one really knows the reason for volatility, but the likeliest reason is trading itself. Imaging that!!! The phenomenon that the trader claims skill in riding is in fact 'created' by his riding!), he generates a notional wealth which in no way reflects the real world's prosperity. If the stock market climbs a thousand point in a day, it does not mean thhat an equivalent amount of assets have somehow been injected into the economy on that day, or that people are living proportionately better lives. Nor do the actual asset creators benefit from this movement, apart from claims of massive market capitalization, which is merely a poor metric of a company's performance. No one benefits, apart from the trader, who without having given anything to the society, has now cornered a good bit of its money.



Trading-for-the-sake-trading is institutionalized gambling. It is cartel which allows power to shift from those who produce to those who merely piggyback. The trader in an assistant's role can never be too big to fail. The role is very important, but one that doesn't necessarily drives our lives.

This brings me to the concept of bank. But that is a discussion for some other day.

Friday, August 19, 2011

Defending or explaining

This hit me today for absolutely no reason. It hit me so hard that I was compelled to sit down quietly and think about it for a while (in the middle of a shitty day at work). It isn't even a big deal but the way it sort of came together in words in my head was amazing.

I use the word 'defend' here in the context of, e.g., Someone says - "Why didn't you come to the party yesterday?" and I say "well, I..." to which the reply is "It's okay. You don't have to defend yourself".

When we defend ourselves we are actually convincing ourselves that whatever we are saying is correct in essence. We want to believe that though we are sugarcoating the facts, the facts themselves remain. In other words, there is some element of guilt involved. And it always shows.

Explaining is when we want to convince other person. We are convinced that we are on the right through and through but somehow the listener has misunderstood. Our attitude towards the whole thing is vastly different.

I understand that the distinction is so fine as to be mostly moot, but like I said, it's not about the idea but about the pristine clarity with which it exploded in my head - Kind of like the first time I actually UNDERSTOOD conditional probability (which was sadly not until the final year of my college education).

Saturday, March 19, 2011

Lyrics - Steppenwolf

A measure of any society can be had by ascertaining how it identifies and treats its renegades. Renegades not in the sense of  criminals, but rather in the sense of non-conformers. What it takes to earn that title, and what are the consequences of having earned it, speak much about the structure, origins and health of the society. Commonality must be stressed, as it is that which we all share that defines a nation or a culture. But resisting change, ostracizing any behaviour other than the mundane is to invite decay. This is the razor's edge that civilization must walk from rise to down fall.

In all this, as in all things with a sort of 'macro' perspective, what gets ignored is the individual. To be broadly stroked in to a 'type', to be a part of the 'masses' provides convenient pigeonholes in which personalities, dreams and hopes can be stuffed willy-nilly as per someone's opinion.

This song is for these renegades, the steppenwolves, who are what they are because they were born or brought up this way. For those who can't ,for no lack of trying, be a part of the pack.


Quivering shadows playing on a hidden lake
air heavy with early winter's taste
if you look closely through the trees you will see
a lonely wolf on the run

brown fur marks him a native of forests unknown
but these snows, he's claimed them and made them his own
by what blood, or love, or sadness does he make he make
so lonely a home

It's not a thing of cities
It's not a thing of men
It's not a thing of pity
It's how a wolf becomes
a Steppenwolf

He was a part of a pack but he never belonged
He was lonely, even when he he wasn't alone
He has tried, and tried, and tried but he
can't lose himself in the hunt

Little things of being a wolf he can't understand
when he loves, his love he cannot explain
he is awkward, or scary, or amused when it's
time to laugh or to mourn

It's not a thing of cities
It's not a thing of men
It's not a thing of pity
It's how a wolf becomes
a Steppenwolf

For some it's easy to pass into the unknown
wolf has taken, the snow to be his home
wilderness retreats the question is
where shall the wild men belong

Friday, March 14, 2008

The Scientific Method # 9

And the last round :

Hi,

Good reply.

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
The natural phenomenon is the territory. The process of enquiry is the
conceps of drawing a map. Sceintific model of enquiry is just one of the
ways of drawing a map. The problem with your argument is that you are
equating one of the instances of the class with the class itself. This
probably comes from the belief that it is the only instance possible. It is
precisely this dogma that I am uncomfortable with. Just as scientific
enquiry, we can possibly have some other kinds of enquiry, which though may
not be as popular as scientifc one, yet may have the potential to explain
natural phenomena.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

Point Taken.

I fully agree with just one reservation, that being your statement-"potential to
Explain natural phenomena."

What are the terms of this explanation? It is easy to say that there is another
way which is better, but you have, till now, offered no requirements from this
radical new method. What is your requirement from this explanation.

What it seems is that you are being nihilistic. You are basically refusing to
Accept any form of proof or explanation. When will you consider a phenomenon
reasonably explained? In what fundamental way will this non-scientific method
of enquiry that you arre seeking difer from the scientific method.?

Just a thought, is this some kind of philosophical socialism?? You know like-
"Science may be correct, but what right does it have to CLAIM that it is correct".
I a thinking of James taggart's thoughts towards Hank Rearden (Atlas Shrugged)
here.

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
The reason for such a belief stems from the fact that scientific inquiry has
advanced quite a lot and is now capable of explaining many concepts. But
this alone does not give us the justification to claim that it IS THE ONLY
MODE OF ENQUIRY POSSIBLE.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Does this sound similar to what I have written above? smile.gif

Read further only after you have read the previous stuff carefully.

We do require a multi-disciplinary approach, but all these disciplines have to
be scientific.

Allow me to explain this.

Most of the aspects of the SPIRITUAL disciplines and schools of thought claim
the existence of the paranormal. Now I am the first to admit that one of the biggest
Drawbacks of science at this time is its inability to fit in our CONSCIOUSNESS
in its frame work.

Just as clearly, our consciousness (aatmaa, soul whatever) is almost the only thing
That the metaphysical disciplines deal with.

I believe that these other schools you keep bringing up are just peddling a twisted
Variant of science right now. Given science's continuous quest to expand its influence,
I belive some things are possible:-

1. That these fields are proven wrong.

2. That it is PROVEN, that these can not be proved/quantified and have to understood
only empirically .e.g. (and this is a somewhat retarded example) :Science may concern
Itself with finding the weight of our souls. Later it may be realised that the concept
of "weight of consciousness" (assuming consciousness and soul to be the same thing)
doesn’t make sense.
It is like the heisenberg's principle- if you cant measure both speed and location of
a particle accurately, it is proven that it is not a failing of your method of measurement
but because of a PROVEN NATURAL PRINCIPLE that it just cant be done.

3. This is the most likely one: That these schools are quantified, and bought into the
fold of science. That is what has happened historically as bastions of mysticism have
fallen to the advances of science. From astronomy to evolution, the same story has been
Repeated in most fields of study that we now associate with science. The holy grail of
Science, in my opinion, is that it should know/explain everything that it can, and to
conclusively prove that what it can not explain can not be explained.

But before any sort of idea about consciousness can be accepted,
it has to fit into the scientific method. It has to be willing to obey the
Hypothesis-experiment-observe-deduce-huypothesise cycle.

The Scientific Method # 8

Sankara's reply :
Hi Kislay,

You have mentioned about the "process of drawing a map" and have equated it
to the mathematical method of representing it in terms of symbols and
formulae.i believe your analogy is incorrect.


The natural phenomenon is the territory. The process of enquiry is the
conceps of drawing a map. Sceintific model of enquiry is just one of the
ways of drawing a map. The problem with your argument is that you are
equating one of the instances of the class with the class itself. This
probably comes from the belief that it is the only instance possible. It is
precisely this dogma that I am uncomfortable with. Just as scientific
enquiry, we can possibly have some other kinds of enquiry, which though may
not be as popular as scientifc one, yet may have the potential to explain
natural phenomena.

The reason for such a belief stems from the fact that scientific inquiry has
advanced quite a lot and is now capable of explaining many concepts. But
this alone does not give us the justification to claim that it IS THE ONLY
MODE OF ENQUIRY POSSIBLE. I think, what we require is a multi disciplanary
approach. We need to draw lessons from metaphysics, easterm mysticism and
others schools of thought. Or in fact, a systematic study of Vedas should
also help us understand many natural phenomena. Its not without reason that
Dayanand Saraswati asked us to go back to the vedas.

The Scientific Method # 7

My work :
Hi,

ALL RIGHT, it took me one night to see why your second arguments about the
map And the map maker sounds so plausible even though I know it is crap. But
I think I finally got it.

So here goes.

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
1.You believe maps are not independent of territory. Perfectly agree, 100%.
But you also seem to suugest that territory is not independent of maps. It
is this backward mapping from concepts to reality that I object to.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

You misunderstood me about the two way mapping. What I meant was that if I
Understood a map, I could picture the territory by using it. Also if I was
actually Standing in that territory, I would be able to visualize what part
of THAT PARTICULAR MAP it is. The territory is definitely completely
independent of the map. It Would exist independent of the existence of any
map.

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
2. you believe maps are true representation of territory.
I contest this. Maps are just a perspective of the map-maker about the
territory. If map maker changes, so does the map
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

Now this is what was bugging me. What you are saying is true.
But here you are being inconsistent with your own initial problem statement,
viz, the ability of science to help explain phenomena.

If the map maker changes, so does the map. Correct. But it still remains a
map.
Situation being analogous to multiple scientific theories to explain a
single phenomenon, One or more of which may be fully or partioally correct.

What you ORIGINALLY said that is there a way of doing this without maps at
all. You wanted something which would put you yourself IN the territory,
instead of you having to infer the territory from the map.

Change the map maker as many times as you will, you still need a map.

Maps are representations their makers perspective on the teriitory??? As
both you and I agree, The territory is a fact. It does not brook any
perspective on it. All you can do is choose HOW to represent this fact. The
map maker has to present his Key to the map in advance. He may be Somewhat
incorrect. Some road may be longer or shorter than what it appears to be in
the map.Then the maker has to make the effort of corrcting his map as soon
as such a flaw is found.

What I mean to say is:
You may find faults with a map or a map maker, but you can not fault the
CONCEPT OF DRAWING MAPS To represet territory. The only way for you to
actually BE IN THE TERRITORY to use your mind to Understand a map.

What you are saying about locality maps is bullshit. I don't need a map of
my locality Because I already have it in my head. And the map in my head has
much more detail than Would be found in a usual map, but it's a map a map
nonetheless.
Everytime I take a left
from the paan waala to reach the playground I am referring that map
subconsciously.

But I will need that locality map if you want to know what is the cumulative
length of all the roads in my colony. It is requied for quantitative
measure.

Similarly, what suport tools do you want to do away with? Since you are very
comfortable with English can you do away with the grammar or punctuation???
If you are very worried about Delta T Then allow me to remind you that as
far as understanding the territory of natural phenomena goes You don't need
that abstraction. It comes into the map only when you try to obtain a
quantitative measure of phenomena. It is like scale of the map, not required
if you want only a general layout Of the territory but required if you want
to measure it.

I hope THAT has killed your little unscientific rebellion smile.gif

Kis~

The Scientific Method # 6

Sankara answers :

<<<<<<<
In what terms will I know it? In what terms will I describe it? Other than
probably Saying "I'm moving damn fast!!!!!" which doesn't mean
anything.That's what I mean when I say that understanding presupposes a mode
of expression.
>>>>>>>>.

Well, nobody is doubting the fact that we need symbols to convey the ideas.
The question that I am posing is, are these symbols adequate( or rather
necessary) to describe the phenomenon. Just because of the fact that we make
use of mathematical symbols does not mean that mathematical symbols alone
can describe it. It just proves that we are used to mathematics so much
that, we find it difficult to understand anything without symbols.

Also u need mathematical symbols only if u want to express your motion in
terms of mathematical symbols. Say, you are running, can you not compare
your running speed at different points in time? Can you not know when you
are jogging and when sprinting? Do you need mathematical symbols to realize
that there is some change in velocity? You may argue that, u may not be able
to specify the speed at a particular point in time. But is not "speed at a
particular instant" itself a construct of mathematics? Suppose man has not
invented mathematics. U are not aware that there is something called speed,
vector velocity etc. Can you not intuitively tell that a state of rest is
different from a state of motion or for that matter, a state of higher
velocity ( sprinting ) is different from a state of low velocity? (jogging)

Just to prove my point, why does a deer run very fast when it sights a
predator?. When it is sure that it is relatively safer, it slows down. You
may argue that it does not need to communicate like humans do. We make this
statement because it does not communicate like the way we do. Its quite
possible that it is aware of its "speed" and uses a system of symbols and
signs that is quite different from us and also tells this to its "friends".
So to experience motion or to understand motion, I believe, mathematical
symbols are no neccessity. But if we want to describe motion so as to fit it
into the mathematical framework that we have built up, I think we need
mathematics.

Also your statement that I am moving damn fast makes a lot of sense if you
can convince yourself that there are alternate ways of describing it other
than X km/hr. I am moving damn fast says that

1. I am moving
2. I am sprinting, probably running at my maximum speed. ( I know my maximum
speed intuitively but I don't know what is it in km/hr. depending upon your
point of interest, you can consider it as half full or half empty).

Chalo, expecting a massive mail from you


Best Regards,
Sankara Narayanan


And again a followup mail saying :

Now talking of Capra's "map for territory"

I am perfectly with you on the fact that mathematical symbols are like the
maps. It seems, u have not correctly understood my objection. My objection
is not against symbols as representation of the phenomenon. My objections
are

1.You believe maps are not independent of territory. Perfectly agree, 100%.
But you also seem to suugest that territory is not independent of maps. It
is this backward mapping from concepts to reality that I object to.

2. you believe maps are true representation of territory.
I contest this. Maps are just a perspective of the map-maker about the
territory. If map maker changes, so does the map

Now coming to the need for maps.

I believe maps are not essential. You can still understand without the maps.
Just to prove my point, Do u need a map of your colony? Don't u feel u know
more than what the map actually tells u? So should we not do a similar thing
in science as well. When we have understood certain phenomena, should we not
try to do away with the support tools just like we are doing away with the
locality maps? This has been the crux of my argument so far. I believe if
one can explain a phenomenon or for that matter, a concept when he can
define it without any jargon.

The Scientific Method # 5

My reply:

Hi,

Writing this after reading both your mails.

>>>>>>>>>>>>
Can you not describe your motion at every single instant of time?
>>>>>>>>>>>>

In what terms will I know it? In what terms will I describe it? Other than
probably Saying "I'm moving damn fast!!!!!" which doesn't mean
anything.That's what I mean when I say that understanding presupposes a mode
of expression.

>>>>>>>>>>>>
what do I do if I want to know its motion both in space domain and time
domain simultaneously?
>>>>>>>>>>>>
Suppose you want to tell what an elephant looks like from front and behind.
Can you say it using a single language construct? You will have to say it in
2 different statements.

Man you can know it but HOW WILL YOU SAY/EXPRESS IT? All external symbols
and formulae are means to conveying that to-fro motion of the pendulum. You
are falling into Kapra's "map for territory"
Trap - thinking that symbols mean something independently of the phenomena
they are attached to.
They do not. They are a map using which you have to visualise the territory.

>>>>>>>>>>>
Another point with the usage of mathematics for this approximation.
Science
in its attempt to make a discrete event as continuous as possible,
introduces the concept of "dt" or 'delta t'. Science has not given a
scientific, mathematical definition of 'delta t'. The definition is of
intuitive nature and to make it mathematical, have introduced the idea of
limits. (tending to zero but not equal to zero. Is it not a proof enough of
the inadequacy of science to explain phenomena?
>>>>>>>>>>>

"Delta t" is a way of saying that however small a change is, maths can track
it. Observe that the Final deliverables of maths, i.e., equations, don't
have deltas in them.

V = u + at ---------- 1
may be derived using delta but as an 'end-user', you are free to enter any
random time instant/interval in this equation.
Delta T is way of modelling an arbitrary precision time interval.


>>>>>>>>>>>
Can you not describe your motion at every single instant of time? When
you are doing a scientific
analysis, are you not taking snapshots at discrete intervals and then
trying to construct a
continuous picture out of it?
>>>>>>>>>>>

Yes I am. And I can tell you that I am successful because now you can
enter any value of t in
Equation 1 and the answer would be correct. I would consider that
damning evidence in favour of
the scientific method!!!

>>>>>>>>>>>
We both know that y(t)= A sin(w*t) is different from y(t) = A'cos(w'*t).
When I say understanding it,I mean I should be able to able to identify
that
there is some difference between these two, without constructing their
equations.
>>>>>>>>>>>

Without showing me the equation, what will you say? How would you convey
to me the difference between
the two?

>>>>>>>>>>>
Can we define acceleration as something more than dv/dt?
>>>>>>>>>>>

Well we definitely can!!!! All bike/car enthusiasts define it as 0 to
100 kmph in x seconds :-)
Even here you see that all these guys need this figure to express how
fast a bike is, and looking
at this figure( the analog for physics equations), a bike enthusiast
will know how slow or fast a bike is.

The Scientific Method # 4

Parry and thrust from shankar :

<you want to know its location 3 seconds from now?>>

Contrast this approach with the approach that I am talking about. Instead of
analysing the motion of particle, u somehow transfer yourself into the
particle. Its like u have got into the particle and moving along with it.
Would not your understanding of the motion of particle now would be better
than what it was with the external analysis by scientific method? Can you
not describe your motion at every single instant of time? When you are doing
a scientific analysis, are you not taking snapshots at discrete intervals
and then trying to construct a continuous picture out of it? At the first
time, the difference is huge because the intervals are large. You refine the
process by decreasing the inter-frame interval and come closer to a
continuous motion at every attempt. However hard you may try u will never
get a really continuous motion as you there is a fundamental conflict
between the two objects (one is discrete and other continuous . To get a
truly continuous frame, you need to have the inter-frame interval zero,
which is not possible in scientific analysis.


Another point with the usage of mathematics for this approximation. Science
in its attempt to make a discrete event as continuous as possible,
introduces the concept of "dt" or 'delta t'. Science has not given a
scientific, mathematical definition of 'delta t'. The definition is of
intuitive nature and to make it mathematical, have introduced the idea of
limits. (tending to zero but not equal to zero. Is it not a proof enough of
the inadequacy of science to explain phenomena?


To give you a even better idea of what I am talking about, say Kislay is in
motion. I capture all his movements for about one hour and apply scientific
analysis on it. I have a wealth of information about Kislay's movement. I
know what was your velocity at a particular time period ( I still doubt, if
science can provide me the information at a particular instant) and you will
not be aware. Yet, I believe you can understand your motion in a much better
sense that I can I ever hope to do. You can, if you want, describe your
motion at a particular instant of time while I cant.

Its already been a long mail, rest in next.

Best Regards,
Sankara Narayanan


And the missive immediately following this reads thus :

Now coming to the SHM problem, what do I do if I want to know its motion
both in space domain and time domain simultaneously? Can science answer it ?
When I say I want to understand the phenomenon, I mean I should be able to
visualize it without any need for external symbols or formulae.
What I mean by understanding SHM, is I should be able to imagine myself as
the pendulum and feel its to- fro motion as if I am the pendulum.

We both know that y(t)= A sin(w*t) is different from y(t) = A'cos(w'*t).
When I say understanding it,I mean I should be able to able to identify that
there is some difference between these two, without constructing their
equations.

Don't u think, we should have a website, that explains these physics
concepts in an intuitive way.

Can we define acceleration as something more than dv/dt?

Best Regards,
Sankara Narayanan

The Scientific Method # 3

My elaborate reply to the original question:

Hi,

"The essence of the phenomenon" and "I mean can u feel its motion?" make
your mail sound very Hegelian.

Hegel was a philosopher who said that it is futile to analyse. If you
analyse the motion of billiards balls striking each other on the billiards
table, then you are incorrect in doing so as you are only analysing your own
concepts (like force, momentum etc.) and not "the essence of the
phenomenon", as you have put it. The Analysis doesn't help you know the
events reality, to feel it.

So much for Hegel. You might like to read him.

I feel that you are not asking your questions properly. What, precisely do
you mean when you say "understand" the motion of a particle in space? Do you
want to know with what it will move in the next split second? Do you want to
know its location 3 seconds from now? There is no pooint saying I want to
understand the particle. It has nothing to understand. Scientific enquiry
will answer the questions you pose to it. Different questions asked of the
same phenomenon will yield different answers, but that is not because the
phneomenon has changed or science is wrong, but only because a different
question.

BTW you might want to ask yourself-what it is that you mean by the essence
of the phenomenon?

Consider a wave on a string. What is the nature of this phenomenon? If you
observe the wave in time domain, it appears as a disturbance flowing from
one point in space to another. If you observe it in space domain (i.e.
observe any point on the string), it appears as plain SHM. So this is not a
fallacy of science. You ask different questions, you get different asnwers.

It must be said here that the concept of understanding presupposes a mode of
expressing that understanding. All the equations and formulae are that mode
in science. The real problem, when you ask questions like this "essesnce of
phenomenon", is that you haven't grasped the mapping from equation to
phenomenon. Think of this like ED- "a cube is lying on ite edge with one of
the face at 45 degrees to VP....". To solve this we need to visualize this.
THAT is the essence of the phenomenon that is this cube. Analogy can be
extended to physics. You can be said to understand only when you know the
mapping both ways and go from one expressions to the other easily.

This, incidentally, is the great problem of how to teach Physics in a better
way in our schools and colleges. So many people I have met know all the
equations for light cones but can not map it to an intuitive concept.

Hope this doesn't sound gibberish.

Kis~

The Scientific Method # 2

My first reply:

Hey,

In my opinion, both your statements are correct.

Vis-s-vis the second statement, I would like emphasise that I don't mean
that the process of scientific enquiry is wrong.
By the process I mean the hypothesise-test-conclude-rehypothesise(if
wrong) process. What I mean is that we may not at all times know what
questions to ask and how to ask them. This might introduce problems in the
scientific process.

Am I clear or do I need to write one of my trademark massive mails?? smile.gif

Kis~


And to this mail, shankar replied :

I do not mind your trademark massive mails.

But do you think, certain formulae and certain equations can capture the
essence of the phenomenon?

Say for example, u want to understand the motion of a particle in space?
What do u think will be the best way to "understand it". By understanding
it, I mean can u feel its motion?


Best Regards,
Sankara Narayanan

The Scientific Method # 1

What follows is series of emails tossed between Me and Shankara (Similar to the series on the TAo of Physics). This post contains the mail stating a question regarding the scientific method posed by shankar. Posts following this on have all the back and forth.


Kislay,

Let me pose this question to the objectivist.

Do u think, scientific analysis can help us understand an object?
Or you believe, scientific analysis is far from perfect?

Best Regards,
Sankara Narayanan

Thursday, September 20, 2007

On the Tao Of Physics#6

And Mr. Sankara replies:

Hi kislay

Have read ur entire mail. Ur arguments about UNIX processes is quite interesting to read. Nice one, I must say.
As far as bomb case is concerned, u have got me wrong, I was quoting it to substantiate my arguments regarding not being receptive about a particular thing and not as an example for instinct.

Yes, we are talking about a hard gained skill. What Capra is trying to say probably is that the efforts needed for getting that "hard gained skill" is very similar to what an eastern mystic goes through. That's why he made a comparison.

Also I talked to Gaurav Singh ( COE guy, jo bahut lamba hai and b-ball team captain)about ur post. He also said something very similar about instinct being the result of subconscious mind. In fact that's what they are trying to model in their idea for a paper on automatic essay evaluation. So I think we do have a convergence of views there.

I am not arguing about that UNIX process thing as I don know anything about neural networks or that feyman's theories. So I reserve my comments. If at all I do get something to read on that and if I don agree with u, I shall raise those points.

Also, I think I am understanding objectivism now. For more I read about hindu philosophy ( once again the vedantic philosophy which considers vedas as the defining text on hinduism), I feel there is some sort of convergence between the vedic philosophy and objectivism. I plan to read some books on hindu philosophy, notably works of vivekananda and some commentaries of adi shankara on various upanishads etc.

Once I read that, I think I wud have a decent understanding of hinduism and will be able to better comment on the following question.

"Has Ayn Rand, been inspired by certain ideas of our philosophy?"

Also, I suggest u try reading few of those and more importantly try to get the true meaning of it by transcending the obvious ones.

How is the work pressure there? Did u finally understood your role in the organization?

Now that CAT notification is out, I am back to square one as far as clarity of my career path is concerned.

Regards
shankar

On the Tao Of Physics#5

This is the mail I wote after having gone through Sankara's replies. It is mostly concerned with instinct and the origins of Epiphany.

Hi,

How you doing man. Project fine?STM still not bankrupt eh???

>>>>
I feel everybody is born with it. Everybody can perceive things which cannot be justified by reasons of logic, but just we feel it.

If u remember Alchemist, we have something similar saying that nature always gives us signals. We need to listen to them. If we regularly overlook it, we feel the signals have stopped comin...... Along these lines.
What I feel is we stop being receptive about it.
>>>>

Really can't say anything about what Paulio Coelho has written. I think it is a critical case of words and phrases being inappropriate/insufficient to convey what he meant when he wrote "Maqtub" in that book.

What I understand is this-Instinct is the knowledge which comes before conceptualization of the problem. Imagine someone punches you and you see the punch coming fro the corner of your eyes. You duck (hopefully) and what makes you do it is instinct.

>>>>
Why lay man does not get that instinct.
1. lay man does not even know the objective of the experiments. Even if he gets a result he cant make sense of itfor the raeson that he is not aware
that such a problem exists.
Say if i pull out the wire and give u a bomb, u wud realize what it is and run away. But if u never knew that such a thing like bomb existed, how wud u identify it. For u it is nothing more than a round ball.

2.he does not actually set out to look for it. Its like it, u know a signal is coming on a particular channel. All these years u were not tuned to it. So u never realize the transmission. The research, training etc that is being talked about is for the correct tuning.
>>>>

Understanding the objective of the problemis outside the domain of instinct. I think the problem here is that we are confusing extremely hard gained skill with instinct.
Consider a golie in football.In penalties, he can be said to be jum,ping left or right on 'instinct' but is it really so? Would you then say that the players at the highest level of the game have greater instinct or greater skill. You or I would have absolutely no clue of what to do.

As for the bomb-you said it yourself. My 'throwing it away' does not constitute instinct at all.It is a conscious decision taken so fast that even I cant consciously follow the chain of decisions.

So in my opinion, A layman having not getting those epiphanies but a scientist getting them has nothing to do with instinct.

Another point that I would like to raise in this regard is that of the subconscious mind. It is well known fact that even when we have banished some thought from our mind it persists in the subconscious.e.g. we are trying to remember a name but cannot recall it.Then several hours later we suddenly remember it.

I like to think of our mind as one huge UNIX machine which is extremely likely to create orphan processes. Even when you have killed the active process, the neural circuits still bear the computation as it is not possible to them all due to the highly decentralized structure of a neural network.This 'orphan' process may ,later on, come up with a solution, which the mystics/philosophers/godmen claim to have as a godsend or instinct.

Your point about no reaction without knowledge is exactly the one I am trying to make. The 'instinct'of the scientist is his subconscious mind come up with a solution.

>>>>
And for the last question,capra has himself given a very good account of it. They were not able to get that brainwave earlier because they were looking
in other direction. The moment physicists started looking for it( as an eastern mystic does)they were able to get it.
>>>>

By all accounts, the eastern mystic does not look in any direction at all. He is sitting there trying to calm down all his 'orphan' processes to extract 'maximum' performance from them.

Just consider this:
Consider some huge problem like 'who made this universe?' or some such. If you know of swarm intelligence, you will know that in them we consider ALL POSSIBLE SOLUTIONS (kinda like FEYNMAN'S SUM OVER HISTORIES) and gradually converge to the best solution. But the problem with our mind is that in our mind we are carrying so many deeply ingrained filters regarding what is possible and what is not. So the result thrown by the orphan processes I just mentioned are being actively filtered out when we try to intellectualize the problem. And that cant lead us to a solution as the solution demands that all possible alternatives be considered.

Here states like meditating or sleeping come to limelight. From a technical/scientific point of view, these states are a SUSPENSION OF DIBELIEF-a state where our filters are suspnded so that our neural circuit can realize the full potential of that swarm intelligence process running in the background.

Hence Kekule's six snakes dream. I belive it was not a dream about snakes at all. It was one of the possible solutions given by his mind. He subsequently described it as snakes as a sort of verbal approximation. Or his mind, represented its result in the form the imagery it found to be closest to what the result actually was.

>>>>
Just to give an example, do u remember how Kekule came up with the structure of benzene. For us, it wud have been a bad dream about snakes but for him that was an insight, a hint by nature, which his instinct interpreted correctly. It came just by chance, he did not try to get that dream
>>>>

They say you can not find it if you look for it. I think the hypothesis of the 'orphan process' and the mental filters explains this koan beautifully.